Home

 

 

Editing is Like Dieting

By Rich Spector

Oh sure, you’ve heard “Trim the Fat” and “Cut, Cut, Cut.” But what does that mean? Someone once told me to pretend an editor is going to pay me one hundred dollars for every word I cut. I ended up with “Once upon a time, they lived happily ever after.”

So what’s fat? Does cutting mean: Here’s my character - Here’s his problem - Here’s how he solved it? BORING! Fat free white cheese on fat free white bread with fat free mayo. No thanks, I’d rather starve.

Of course it doesn’t mean that. Here’s what I’ve learned. You need to cut fat and add spice.

Let me explain. Start simply by writing the whole thing down. Don’t summarize it or discuss it with anyone. Both will cause you and your story to lose enthusiasm and momentum. And don’t leave out a word. That is the most important first step. You must give your ideas room to breathe, live and develop.

Then, reread it without stopping to fix punctuation, grammar or anything. Make sure you’ve told a good story. Not great, yet. Just good. Let your main character tell you if you’ve been successful. Make the changes she tells you to make. She knows best. It’s her story.

Now comes your part. The hard part. Remember, editing is like dieting. You have to cut out the fudge brownies. You have to give up the extra cheese.

Important Rule: Every word must develop the character and plot.

This does not mean cut out all the beautiful poetic language. That’s the spice. But those spices MUST develop the character and plot. Words that don’t are the fat. Don’t forget your words also need rhythm. The words are the train and the rhythm is the track. Sorry for mixing metaphors but together they make up your story’s unique voice.

This is painful and it requires discipline. But in the morning, you’ll be able to look in the mirror and be proud of the great results.


© Copyright 2004 New Jersey Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators

No part of this website may be reproduced without written permission from this site's Webmaster